Wednesday, October 8, 2008

No Controversy Over Controversial Issues Policy?

On Monday, the new policy concerning "controversial" events on campus was unveiled.

So far, I have heard no outcry, but perhaps few have slogged all the way through the policy's vague, legal wording, or have missed, among procedural tedium, its broader implications.

Here's the line that sent up a red flag for me:
"...such controversial issues are to be engaged during, prior to, or subsequent to, the presentation, in light of Catholic teachings..."

The hammer comes down. No ifs, ands, or buts. Doesn't matter what the topic is. The discussion must include religion.

I had a problem with this last year during the Corvino controversy, and I still do. What will this entail? A religious authority coming in as a kind of tag line...there's a lot of gray in this issue, but here's what you should believe? That was what was proposed with Corivino.

I suppose that at least with some forewarning of this requirement, the event planners will at least be allowed to choose who represents Catholic teaching and how.

I'm curious to see it in action, and I wonder what its first test run will be.

In the meantime, I'm still pushing for protection of gay students on campus, another necessary action made obvious last year by the Corvino event. Sexual orientation and gender identity remain conspicuously absent from our non-discrimination policy.

1 comment:

Ginger said...

Kyla -

Several years ago, in an "orientation class" (a phrase which, as the hours passed,I realized was acting as a replacement for "how we do things here") for new teachers in a nearby suburban school district, we were introduced to the district's enlightened list of persons who would not be discriminated against within the schools. Markedly absent was any reference to gender or sexual orientation, and when asked, the person said quite openly that "the district's community was not yet ready to add those categories to the list, but were nonetheless very accepting of all." What a bunch of hooey....

Grandma G